This spaghetti carbonara recipe follows the authentic Roman method: five ingredients, no cream, and a silky sauce made from eggs, Pecorino Romano, guanciale fat and starchy pasta water. It takes 25 minutes from start to finish and serves four. This recipe is not test-cooked by RoamFeast, and the nutrition figures are estimates.
What makes this carbonara authentic
Authentic Roman carbonara uses five ingredients only: guanciale, eggs, Pecorino Romano, black pepper and pasta. There is no cream, no garlic, no onion, no milk, no butter and no herbs in the standard Roman recipe. The silky sauce is an emulsion of egg yolks, finely grated Pecorino Romano, rendered guanciale fat and starchy pasta water, tossed together off the heat. Cream makes the sauce heavy and masks the flavour of the cheese and pork, which is why a recipe with cream is a different dish, not the Roman original. The strict five-ingredient version that Romans defend today only settled in the 1990s; cream appeared in Italian printed recipes through the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s. This recipe follows the standard five-ingredient version, so it leaves out garlic and olive oil too. The Accademia Italiana della Cucina's published version does include a clove of garlic and a spoonful of olive oil, but most Roman recipes omit both, and this one does as well.
The ingredients
Every ingredient earns its place, and there is nowhere to hide a weak one in a five-ingredient dish. Start with 400g of good bronze-die dried spaghetti, 100g per person; rigatoni is the traditional alternative, and its ridged tubes trap the sauce well. The pork is 150g of guanciale, cured pork cheek, with the rind removed and cut into short strips about 1cm thick. Guanciale has a higher fat content than pancetta and a deeper, more savoury flavour that defines the dish. If you cannot find it, unsmoked pancetta is the accepted substitute; it is milder and slightly less fatty, so the finished dish tastes a little different. Do not use smoked bacon, because the smoke overpowers the delicate egg and cheese sauce. The eggs are 4 large yolks plus 1 large whole egg, all at room temperature; the yolks give richness and help the emulsion hold, while the whole egg adds body and loosens the sauce slightly. The cheese is 80g of Pecorino Romano, grated very finely to a powder so it melts smoothly; pre-grated cheese is not recommended, because anti-caking agents stop it melting cleanly. Some Roman cooks soften the sharpness with a mix of three parts Pecorino to one part Parmigiano Reggiano, but Parmesan alone is not the Roman standard. Finish with 1 to 2 teaspoons of freshly and coarsely ground black pepper, used generously, because pepper is one of the five ingredients, not a garnish. Salt the pasta water lightly, about 1 teaspoon of fine sea salt per litre, because Pecorino Romano and guanciale are both salty. Reserve about 150ml of the starchy pasta water before draining; its starch is what binds the emulsion.
How to make spaghetti carbonara
Carbonara comes together fast, so have everything ready before the pasta goes in. Whisk the eggs, Pecorino and pepper into a thick paste first, and cook the guanciale in a cold pan until its fat renders and the edges turn crisp and golden. Cook the spaghetti until very al dente, about 1 minute less than the packet time, and reserve about 150ml of the starchy pasta water before draining. The sauce is made off the heat: the pan must be off the heat before the egg mixture goes in, because eggs begin to thicken at around 65C and a flame under the pan turns them to scramble in seconds. Toss the hot pasta through the guanciale fat, then pour the egg and cheese paste over it and toss vigorously and continuously, adding the hot pasta water a splash at a time until the sauce turns glossy and coats every strand like silk. The starch in the pasta water is what binds the emulsion. Serve immediately in warm bowls, because the sauce tightens as it cools.
Mistakes to avoid
These are the mistakes that spoil a carbonara most often: Adding cream. It is the most common mistake outside Italy, and it makes a different dish. Cooking the eggs over direct heat, which scrambles them in seconds. Using smoked bacon instead of guanciale or pancetta. The smoke overpowers the sauce. Using Parmesan alone instead of Pecorino Romano. Parmesan alone is not the Roman standard. Using pre-grated cheese, which does not melt cleanly. Using cold eggs straight from the fridge, which are more likely to clump when they meet the hot pasta. Salting the pasta water heavily, then finding the dish too salty. The cheese and pork are salty already. Adding peas, mushrooms, garlic or onion and still calling it authentic. Those additions make a different dish.